Life is like music; it must be composed by ear, feeling, and instinct, not by rule.

Wednesday, September 1, 2010

What's the point of the Track?

I read an article last night from a coach that doesn't believe in track work outs unless his runners are going to race on the track. But, for runners that will only run road races on hard surfaces or trails, he said the track work outs are practically useless. This got me to thinking, which is quite dangerous as you all know :).

I only run road races and trail races so I was intrigued by this line of thinking. Here's what he had to say on the subject as it relates to runners focused on 5k racing (which is me of course but it can apply to other distances):

"Some runners bristle at leaving the security of the track. Let's face it, there's comfort in the perfect 400m oval and the equally perfect splits we can record while running around it. But, that's the problem. Road 5k's are not prefect ovals. We won't record perfect splits as we dodge runners, climb hills, and make 180-degree turns. Our goal is to become efficient at the race we're training to run, and training on trails and the road is the best way to make that happen."

This resonated with me so much that I ditched my group track session this morning and did my own speed work on the dirt trails and I loved it. After a 20 min. warm-up, I did 6x800 meter intervals at 5k pace with 2 min. recovery . . . it was awesome. I also had some thoughts while running which I think supports this approach. First, why train on a soft high energy return track which can give you a false sense of your capabilities (again, this doesn't apply if you actually race on the track). The track I run on is so soft and nice and you can run really fast splits but it doesn't relate to actual racing in terms of terrain. Also, it's harder to run fast on dirt so wouldn't you want to train on the hard stuff and race on the easy stuff as opposed to training on the really easy stuff then trying to race on the harder stuff (i.e., the track I run on is easier than roads).

I think Gordo and Tuck might agree that the last 5k we ran together, the track would have been useless to prepare you for that type of 5k and terrain. It had bends, curves, and a nightmare of a long gradual hill, with mixed hard surface and dirt.

And lastly, there very few things in life is as boring as running around the same oval track, over and over.

HHH

Saturday, August 28, 2010

Hips, Salsa, MWU3's and Suspended Evo's

Prior to this last discovery, I've had 4 life changing moments in my brief 3 year running career. First was the day I found Barefoot Ken Bob and BFT. Second was the day I took off my shoes and starting running barefoot. Third was the day I found KSO's because they taught me I didn't need traditional marshmallow shoes to run. Fourth was working on my foot placement and changing from a severe forefoot landing to a whole foot or mid-foot landing which is also controlling my supination a bit which reduced the pressure on the outside forefoot (I have severe). Now, the Fifth is meeting Janet and discovering my hips. The last 48 hours has been pretty amazing. I run 6 days a week and I take Monday's off. I alternate hard runs and easy runs and Saturday is my easy run day and my legs are usually starting to get tired by the weekend.

My normal Saturday run is about 45 min. at 8:30 - 8:45 pace. However, this morning I knocked off almost 6 miles at 6:47 pace and the amazing thing is my effort level was the same as it normally is for a easy run. Although I carry a Garmin watch, I run mostly by "perceived" effort, that is, I know by my effort level about how fast I'm running. So, this morning I gave a normal easy effort and didn't look at my Garmin until about 30 min. into the run (after warm-up) and I was running around a 6:45 pace, I continued for a few more minutes and shut down the run. I stopped because I was stunned because all I did was really concentrate on my hips, landing under my body and pretending (as Janet said) a lasso was around my waste pulling me forward. After about 10 minutes, all I thought about was cycling the hips through and running straight (I never thought about foot plant/strike at all).

And here's the tell/tell, I had absolutely no Achilles pain (or PF pain) after the run. Normally, after a hard run, I can have some minor Achilles pain but it goes away in a few hours. This time I had no pain and had no pain the entire day while walking other than the annoying bending on my Evo's that I used to walk.

I should mention that my Evo's are on suspension and I'm running in my MWU3's. First, I'm doing so because my new coach said I run "substantially" better in the MWU3's vs. Evo's and the video taped proved it. Second, for whatever reason, I have no pain running in the MWU3's even though they have a 9mm heel differential. I can't explain it but the MWU3's feel really good (maybe it's my change to the mid-foot strike).

I'm doing the hip exercises twice a day and I can already feel a lot more flexibility. My new coach said you generate power primarily from 3 areas: feet, hips and arms. I was generating all my power from my feet and it's amazing I never got hurt but it explains the different pains in my feet (the good thing is it shows how strong are feet are to handle that level of stress and pressure). She told me to evenly distribute the power generation and in addition to my hips I've tweaked my arm placement and the results have been pretty incredible so far. I feel like I'm 4 inches shorter when I run and it feels odd at first but once I get going, it feels amazing. She told me that while we don't run exactly like horses to still think about the incredible power horses generate from their hips.

HHH


Thursday, August 26, 2010

Video Gait Results

I'll write much more later and I haven't had a chance to digest everything because it was an incredible session (almost 2 hrs.). When you are sitting there listening to someone (Janet Runyan) that was the #1 female finisher of the Leadville 100 (21:47:44), and finished #10 overall, you are in a bit of awe to start with (at least I was). Anyway, the session was amazing.

She videotaped me running in my Evo's, Mizuno Wave Universe 3's and Nike Free Run+ (zero dropped), on packed dirt roads. After about 5 minutes of running, she told me all my work needs to be done above the waist. She said my legs, feet, foot placement, etc. was very good (she said I had a perfect mid-foot strike and not to mess with it at all). She said I slightly would over-stride at times but it was nothing she was worried about and said if I corrected my problems above the waist and specifically my hips, mid section and arms, then the slight over-striding at times would self correct. Literally, we spent the bulk of the session doing hip exercises and my hips are actually sore. She said power is generated by the hips and the arms working in conjunction with the hips, and the feet but that I was using my feet too much and I was relying on my feet to do too much instead of also using my hips to generate power and speed. She gave me a set of hip exercises to do every day as a warm-up before running.

As for the shoes, this was very interesting. She said I run "significantly" cleaner, crisper and with better form in the Mizuno Wave Universe 3's (MWU3) as compared to the Evo's. She said I run pretty well in the Evo's but there's no comparison to the MWU3's. She was I have crisper stride, better upper body control and a slighter shorter and more efficient stride in the MWU3's. As for the Nike Free Run+'s, she recommended I not run in them unless I have to as it slowed down all my mechanics. I definitely have something to think about with my footwear.

Also, she taught classes for many years with Chi founder Danny Dreyer who she knows very well, and she is very familiar with Chi and Pose. She didn't reference either as part of my session but said both had good things to offer, but it was clear as between the two, she preferred Chi for what it's worth. She did say the "lean" described in Chi is very confusing without individual coaching and the "butt kick" in Pose is very different for beginners to understand with coaching.

I told her that funny enough I had been concentrating on my hips but it was a struggle to understand and she said that's the same for anyone as it is practically impossible to understand a phrase like "open up the hips" without individual instruction, otherwise it's just words.

Suffice to say, I'll be taking a few more sessions from her next month.

More coming later and I have a copy of the video running session but I need to make a copy and then post it.

HHH

Monday, August 23, 2010

Practice, Practice, and More Practice

“If I don’t practice for a day, I know it. If I don’t practice for two days, my wife knows it. If I don’t practice for three days, the world knows it.”


HHH

Christopher McDougall's Pick of Minimalist Shoes?

Below is a link to a good post from Christopher McDougall in talking about bio-mechanics expert Lee Saxby. I also find the quote below interesting as he lists the types of minimalist shoes he would wear if he needed protection on rough terrain:

"I’m a fan of form, not footwear. If I need some protection on rough terrain, I like all kinds of minimalist styles: Vibram FiveFingers, the Mizuno Wave Universe, Barefoot Ted’s “Air Luna” huaraches, Terra Plana’s “Evo."

I use the Evo as my primary running shoe while using the Mizuno Wave Universe 3 from time to time.


HHH

Thursday, August 19, 2010

"Double Zero Drop" Nike Free 3.0's










Had the cobbler zero drop my Nike Free 3.0's for the second time. The first time, he dropped them to 11mm with no differential heel to toe and this time he took the same pair and reduced them to 3.5mm which is the most you can reduce the 3.0 without ruining the shoe.

They feel amazing, just like a glove. They weigh 4.0 oz. without the insole and 4.8 oz. with the insole. I can't wait to test these bad boys tomorrow.

Now, this is truly a Nike 1.0.

The first two pics show the original 3.0, followed by the first "zero drop," and the next 3 pics are the current 3.0's which has been zero dropped a second time.

HHH


Wednesday, August 18, 2010

So What's Up With the Toe Spring?

Toe Spring (William A. Rossi, D.P.M.)

If you rest a shoe, new or old, on a table and view it in profile from the side, it reveals an up-tilt of the toe tip varying from five-eighths to one inch or more. More on worn shoes. This is known as "toe spring" and is built into the last.

On the bare, natural foot the digits rest flat, their tips grasping the ground as an assist in step propulsion. Inside the shoe, the digits are lifted slantwise off the ground, unable to fulfill their natural ground-grasping function.

So why is toe spring built into the last and shoe? To compensate for lack or absence of shoe flexibility at the ball. The toe spring creates a rocker effect on the shoe sole so that the shoe, instead of full flexing as it should, forces the foot to "roll" forward like the curved bottom of a rocking chair. The thicker the sole, such as on sneakers or work boots, or the stiffer the sole (such as on men's Goodyear welt wingtip brogues), the greater the toe spring needed because of lack of shoe flexibility.

With toe spring, the toes of the foot are constantly angled upward five to twenty degrees, depending upon the amount of shoe toe spring. Functionally, they are "forced out of business," denied much or all of their natural ground-grasping action and exercise so essential to exercising of the whole foot because 18 of the foot's 19 tendons are attached to the toes.

The combination of the up-tilted toes caused by the toe spring, and the down-slanted heel and foot caused by the heel wedge angle, create an angle apex at the ball where the two angles converge. The angle apex has a dagger-point effect on the ball. This is certainly an important contributing cause of metatarsal stress symptoms and lesions.

But equally important, the natural gait mechanics are affected. Because the hallux and other digits are largely immobilized by their uptilted position, the step propulsion must come almost wholly from the metatarsal heads. This not only imposes undue stress on the heads, but forces an unnatural alteration of the gait pattern itself.

Thoughts?

For more from Mr. Rossi: http://www.unshod.org/pfbc/pfrossi2.htm.

HHH

Monday, August 16, 2010

Do You Need to Increase Your Stride Rate?

If you compare the ultramarathoners’ technique to world-class distance runners, you will see that the latter maintain effective technique with basically the same stride length throughout the race. Their running form is basically good and remains almost the same throughout the race. They do not resemble the ultramarathoner in technique.

Before you take the advice to shorten your stride, you should understand the relationship between stride length and stride frequency. For example, stride length is the simplest to increase and gives you the greatest increase in running speed. Stride frequency or turnover is more difficult to improve as it takes much greater muscular effort and nervous system involvement. In addition, there is less time for the muscles to “relax” as there is when you have optimal stride length.

The important word here is optimal stride length. Once you achieve your optimal stride length, one that you can comfortably achieve and maintain, then working on turnover becomes most productive. The faster you can improve your stride frequency while maintaining optimal stride length, the faster and further you will go. Simply shortening stride length may enable you to go faster for a short distance, but you will be unable to maintain this speed over a long distance.

A longer stride, however, enables you to go longer with less effort and with greater speed. But if speed is not important and you seek mainly distance and duration, a shorter stride may be best for you. But even here, you will usually fatigue sooner than if you maintained an optimal stride length.

READ MORE HERE . . .http://www.dryessis.com/wp/?p=205

My Thought: Just concentrating on strides per minute (a/k/a cadence) is a mistake. There's a good range you should fall within (84-90+) but the key is to find the optimal stride length and then comfortably increase stride rate without shortening the optimal stride length. I see some beginners that shuffle as they run and that's fine for slower paces over a longer period of time but if you try to increase pace and maintain a shuffle type stride length, it is very difficult to do and only a few runners can maintain that over a longer distance. Many discussions start and end with stride rate and that's misleading.

HHH

Another Good Barefoot Reference

Below is a link to a good article on How to Become a Barefoot Runner.

Let me start by saying I always support good barefoot references, posts and websites. Obviously, the bible of barefoot running starts with Barefoot Ken Bob (http://barefootkenbob.com/), however there are other references to check out.

With respect to the article posted below, let me clarify one thing which is that starting on a soft surface like sand is not a good idea in my opinion. It's more challenging to run on soft surfaces and that also puts additional stress and load on the Achilles tendon primarily and also the plantar muscle. That load will be too much for most beginners. Even grass can be challenging but it's better than sand.

Clean asphalt or concrete is the best surface to learn barefoot running and the easiest surface although that is initially counter-intuitive to many beginners. Ultimately a high school or college track is the best surface for beginners in my opinion as that is generally a clean solid surface (or astro-turf which is a bit harder than natural grass).

Here's a excerpt from the article and a link to the full article:

Why Run Barefoot

  • Running shoes may cause more injuries: Barefoot runners argue that running shoes get in the way of your body’s natural mechanics and cause you to feel more impact when you hit the road. This impact increases the risk of injury in your knees, legs, tendons and shins. If you do wear shoes, you should pick flats: shoes that offer minimal support for your arch and in terms of cushioning.
  • We run better barefoot: An NPR story found that humans are actually supposed to run barefoot: that’s how our bodies were designed. With a little practice weaning ourselves off of shoes, we should run better barefoot, too.
  • You can store more energy: Because barefoot runners land farther forward, on the balls of their feet, the body is better able to store energy. It’s a more efficient way to run, and you can get more mileage out of each run.
  • The feeling: Barefoot runners explain that they just love the feeling of their feet on the pavement (or sand, or trail, etc). It’s a natural, back-to-basics experience that makes them feel more connected to the earth and their exercise.

Let me know what you think.

HHH

Sunday, August 15, 2010

Whole Foot is the Charm

There's many different terms out there such as "forefoot," "mid-foot," "heel," "ball of foot," "whole foot," and "full foot,' that are used to describe a particular foot strike. While many people work away from heel striking to landing somewhere in the front part of the foot, I've actually been working on the reverse in moving from a forward forefoot strike to a whole foot strike, that is, the entire foot landing at the same time. This change has made a dramatic difference by reducing the load on my Achilles and plantar muscle.

I'm not a proponent of Chi running but here is a link to a diagram from the Chi philosophy which I think is pretty good in making a strong case for the whole foot or full foot landing:

HHH

Friday, August 13, 2010

Forefoot vs. Mid-Foot (Follow up)

As a follow-up to the last post on Mid-Foot vs. Forefoot, my friend Pete Larson (a/k/s the "RunBlogger" . . .. you can find him here: http://www.runblogger.com/), sent me some background and further thoughts on the Pose study I referenced.

I won't add any commentary . . . just read it . . . here it is: http://www.sportsscientists.com/2007/09/running-technique-part-ii-sci...

HHH

Forefoot vs. Mid-Foot

I'm spending some time reading studies about the differences between the forefoot and mid-foot landing. In many cases, this causes a lot of confusion because some folks use the terms together such as "forefoot/mid-foot," or "ball of foot," or something else.

One of the studies I read (I've attached the article) stated the following based on analyzing 20 runners (it's a Pose article but I removed the Pose only statements and looked at it in more of a non-bias fashion:http://www.posetech.com/library/pp-damienhowellpt.html). It's a small subgroup but the findings support what I've found about myself having used both the forefoot and mid-foot landing.

1. Heel strikers had greater vertical impact forces than mid-foot or forefoot.
2. Less work done at the knee with forefoot running compared to heel striking and mid-foot running.
3. Great impact at the ankles with forefoot running compared to mid-foot and heel striking.
4. Forefoot running put more stress on the Achilles than mid-foot or heel striking.

It appears clear than heel striking is bad all around. However, the mid-foot vs. forefoot analysis is very interesting. Dr. Lieberman's left mid-foot out of most of his analysis and just said it could results in reduced impacts like forefoot running or could result in increased impacts like heel striking as it will depend on the placement of the forefoot area.

I can personally attest to the differences in impact on the Achilles comparing mid-foot and forefoot running. I think this is key topic area as it is irresponsible to talk about forefoot/mid-foot running without further analysis.

HHH

Thursday, August 12, 2010

Transitioning from Forefoot to Mid-foot

Long story short, after working closely with a coach since Sunday, we've verified that I practically run on my toes. My forefoot strike is extreme and the angle of my foot coming down is too extreme and needs to be leveled out a bit. I'm putting tremendous pressure on my Achilles tendon and plantar muscle. What's amazing is that I haven't injured myself but I do have Achilles pain right after a hard run but it goes away within hours. However, since working on a transition to a mid-foot strike, I have no pain after I run and I'm running faster times with less effort.

I think one of mentors was right when he said it takes 3 years of consistent running, then at that point, you start to learn how to run. In the last 2 months, I've identified this issue and the fact that I wasn't running straight, balanced and aligned which I've fixed and it had a major impact on improving my running (although I didn't exhibit good alignment at the 5k race this past Saturday).

This article by Steve Magness really got my attention: http://www.scienceofrunning.com/2010/08/how-to-run-running-with-proper.html.

I've gone back to really working on my core and hip extensions. On my run yesterday and today, I could already feel my stride lengthen while still landing balanced and under the body. The trick is finding the optimal balance of vertical and horizontal lift coming off the ground, in the air, and landing.

The removing a tremendous amount of stress and pressure by transitioning to more of a mid-foot landing. I use the terms "forefoot," "mid-foot," and "ball of foot," a bit loosely because I think those terms cause incredible confusion in the running community. And, in many circumstances, we are talking about small degrees like landing on the front of the ball of foot, middle of the ball of foot of near the rear of the ball of foot (I'll stop b/c even that can be confusing). Ultimately, for me, I'm landing on the ball of foot with the slightest amount of space before my heel comes down as opposed to a more severe forefoot landing where my heel had a long way to come down and/or didn't touch the ground at all.

I'm not saying a forefoot landing is bad as I don't know that much about bio-mechanics but I'll say this. As a 41 yr. old runner who only started running at 38 yrs. of age, it may be too much to ask to move to a severe forefoot landing . . . it may be too big of an adjustment after 38 yrs. of abusing my body in bad shoes.

I'm still amazed that I've run this way without major injury for over 1 yr. but now that I'm trying to increase performance, speed and efficiency, it's really cool finding all these areas where you can continue to improve.

HHH

Wednesday, August 11, 2010

Running Bio-Mechanics

There’s an excellent article on running bio-mechanics by Steve Magness. Here’s an excerpt that caught my attention since I’m spending a lot of time working on my own bio-mechanics and trying to find my optimal stride. I think this says a lot because I suspect many runners lift the foot off the ground too quickly and/or leave the foot on the ground too long. With that right balance, the body is effortlessly launched forward using its natural springs and energy return.

“Once landing has occurred, it is important to allow the foot to load up. Often, the mistake is made in trying to get the foot off the ground as nquickly as possible, but remember that it is when the foot is on the ground when force is transferred into the ground. While having a short ground contact time is beneficial it should be a result of transferring force faster and not getting quick with the foot. Loading up the foot means allowing it to move through the cycle of initial contact to fully supporting the body. Since initial contact is on the outside of the foot, the support will move inwardly. With forefoot strikers, the heel has to settle back and touch the ground to allow for proper loading. Holding the heel off the ground and staying on the forefoot will not allow for the stretch-reflex on the Achilles-calf complex to occur.”

For the article in its entirety, link here:

http://www.scienceofrunning.com/2010/08/how-to-run-running-with-proper.html

HHH

Monday, August 9, 2010

Threshold Established - Then What?

So one of the many challenges we deal with is determining at what point we can run barefoot-like. For some, it's going 100% barefoot, for others it a true minimalist shoe, for others it racing shoes or XC flats, for others it may be some else. But, after you determine at what point you can run barefoot-like, is there any advantage into migrating further down? That is, for example, if you can run barefoot-like in Bikilas, Treks, Evo's or anything similar to a Saucony Grid Type A-4, should you stop or continue to migrate to something even more minimal?

I think it's an interesting question. If I can run fine with the insole in the Evo, which adds about 2-3mm of protection, what's the advantages of removing more layers? I think we all understand the perception issue so I'm thinking of something more than "it just gives you more ground feel or perception." Does that really matter, if you are running barefoot-like, without injury?

This may be what some of the major shoe companies like Nike and NB are doing. Why develop a true zero drop if, for example, the new Minimus or Nike Free allows people to run more barefoot-like and injury rates are reduced? I'm not saying it's like running barefoot but it's a step toward the goal. If the Minimus improves form and technique and injuries are reduced, why go further?

I think it's an interesting topic. A friend got me thinking about it when he thought I ran in the Evo with the insole and I told him I removed the insole. It got me thinking, if there's no injury or performance difference, why remove the extra protection if it feels good?

HHH


Twitter Updates

    follow me on Twitter

    My Blog List

    My Blog List