Saturday, August 7, 2010
That Commitment Thing Again
Monday, August 2, 2010
Forefoot beat Heel Strike -
Some incredible quotes and statements from one of the top U.S. running coaches.
A Brief Chat With Alberto Salazar and Alan Webb
07/31/2010 11:55 PMBy Amby Burfoot
Photos of Alberto Salazar and Alan Webb by Victah Sailer
American mile record holder Alan Webb hasn't run a race in 14 months, due to a series of injuries, but he's entered in several lowkey European meets next month. And to judge by a workout he ran Tuesday on the Nike campus in Beaverton, Oregon, Webb's headed for some solid performances. With a group of elite U.S. high school runners looking on, including the Rosa twins from New Jersey - the high schoolers were attending a week-long Nike camp – Webb ran a six-mile tempo run on a soft grass oval in 30:05. From there, he jogged quickly to the Michael Johnson track, put on his spikes, and finished off the workout with five smooth looking 200s in 27-28, and a sixth in 24.9.
Solid. And coach Alberto Salazar, monitoring every moment, was well pleased, especially by the 200s. "You see how much more efficient he looks," noted Salazar. "Before he weighed about eight or nine pounds more than now, and his toes pointed out when he ran, and his arms were all over the place. He's much more fluid now. His arms are working in a straighter line. His toes are pointing straight ahead."
Always a tinkerer, always trying to bring new tricks and ideas and performance-improvements to his athletes, Salazar has recently been putting added emphasis on optimal running form. The topic bubbled up a week ago in the announcement that Dathan Ritzenhein was entered in this fall's ING New York City Marathon. It came up again Tuesday in his observations of Webb.
Salazar realizes that changing running form is a tricky, complex subject, but he's not letting that get in the way. Not when great runners like Ritz and Webb encounter injury problems. Not when there are just two years to go until the 2012 Olympics – two years that will pass very quickly. The time to act is now.
Not everyone is convinced that it's a good idea to tinker with running form.
Alberto Salazar: I know. It's not like I think we've got everything figured out. But I believe there are certain principles you have to follow. If you don't, then you begin to develop problems. Everyone seemed so shocked when Dathan ran 12:56 last year. But I wasn't. We took care of a couple of basic biomechanical things. He was holding his hands too low and directing a lot of force into the ground. So we got him to bring the arms up to a 45-degree angle, and to use his hands and arms for more lift. So he was ready to race fast.
During the New York City Marathon conference call, you talked about some more biomechanical work you've done with Dathan this year, I believe. More to prevent recurring injuries.
AS: He was having these metatarsal problems. When we got him running on a forceplate in the Nike biomechanics lab, you could see that he was producing these force spikes under one metatarsal. This was giving him a lot of pain, and we could see why. So we did a couple of things. We worked on his form. He had been leaning forward a too much, with some of the lean actually coming from the waist. So we worked on running straighter and also to go from a heelstrike to more of a forefoot strike.
But when Dathan began bringing his foot down sooner for the forefoot strike, he was hitting the ground harder. I was afraid this would exacerbate his tendency for stress fractures. So we decided to concentrate on just the upper body changes. And it turned out that those alone moved him substantially forward on his footstrike.
He still has the pressure under the metatarsal. You can see it very clearly in our lab. You can see a pressure spike where there shouldn't be one. We decided we could possibly reduce it by excavating some material out of his shoes. At first, Dathan and I literally dug a hole in the midsole. Now Gordon Valiant and our biomechanics guys are making him a sort of dual density midsole with a softer material under the spot where he's coming down hard. It's going to take some fine-tuning, but I'm confident we'll be able to reduce the inflammation in his foot. We're going to retest him a lot. We want to make sure the forces aren't going somewhere else.
Dathan and I both believe that you can't afford to look and run much differently from the top runners. Sure, you can point to great runners who seem to be an anomaly form-wise. But I believe the best runners with the longest careers are those who have the best form.
The Kenyans all look different, and many of them don't last long. But when you look at the top Ethiopians, they have impeccable form and they also have long careers.
There has to be one best way of running. It's got to be like a law of physics. And if you deviate too much from that–the way I did in my career–it can be a big handicap. Dathan can't be a heel striker and expect to run as good as the best forefoot runners. You can be efficient for a while with bad form–maybe with a low shuffle stride – but eventually that's not good for your body. It's going to produce tightness and muscular imbalances and structural problems. Then you get injuries, and if you're not careful – if you don't take care of the muscular and structural issues – the injuries can put you into a downward spiral.
You show me someone with bad form, and I'll show you someone who's going to have a lot of injuries and a short career.
Let's talk about Alan Webb. I was quite impressed by how good he looked today.
AS: Sure. Well you know, he's got so much talent. He just had to get healthy. When he arrived here last September, he had an Achilles problem. We tried every therapy, we visited the best doctors. In the end, he had a simple surgery in mid-December and it showed clearly that his Achilles tendon had become adhered to the covering sheath. Once that was released, he was fine. But during his comeback, and we were very cautious, very conservative, he suffered a calcaneus fracture. So he had to miss more time for that, and we started over again, even more cautiously than before. He's doing like 95 percent of his running on grass and soft trails, and an additional three hours a week on the underwater treadmill.
And that's gone well? What's the hardest he's run?
AS: It has gone very smoothly. I'd say he's been up around 70 miles a week for the last eight weeks. You saw what he did today. That was his longest tempo run, and he finished off the 200s with a pretty fast one. But we haven't been emphasizing speedwork. We want to be careful. It's not important for Alan to run superfast now. It's important that he get his strength and confidence back. He's done workouts like 8 x 800 in 2:13, and
cutdowns of 600-400-300-200 where he'd run three sets in 1:34, 60, 44 and 28.
How fast do you think he might run in Europe?
AS: He's running all lowkey events, a couple of 800s and 1500s. I think he might start off with an 800 around 1:50. By the end of August, he might be ready for a 3:35 to 3:37 for 1500. He'll get faster in time. He could still lose a couple of pounds off his upper body. That will make him quicker and smoother. He's such a responder with strength training, we can't even let him look at weights or he'll put on a couple of pounds of muscle.
[Questions for Alan Webb]
How do you feel about some of the form work you've been doing with Alberto?
Alan Webb: I'm excited for the subtle changes. It's not like it's something I've never done before. But I've been focusing more on it. We're doing more conscious work on it. And I'm adapting. I feel like I'm running well.
Are you excited that you're getting ready to race again?
AW: It's definitely good to be decently fit again after such a long time. In terms of how the races will go, I just don't know. The next month is going to be like starting over again for me. It's going to be a time of self-evaluation. I haven't had a race in 14 months. That's the longest I've gone in my life, since I was beginning to swim as a four-year-old, without some kind of formal sports competition.
That's made it a weird time for me. It's been a tough time. After my strong 2007 season, I set some amazingly high goals. But it seems like all my dreams were crushed after that. I got hit by one thing after another. It hasn't been fun. Now everything seems a lot better. I'm doing the workouts. I'm sleeping better at night. I guess you could say I'm cautiously optimistic.
Thursday, July 29, 2010
3 Yr. Anniversary - Overwhelming to Look Back
Tomorrow represents my 3 year anniversary since I started running consistently. Just for kicks, last night I reviewed my running log over the 3 years. Out of 1,095 days, I ran 915 days and missed 180 days due to rest or injury (of course, I continued to run through most of my injuries). I approximately ran 84% of the time. My goal was to achieve 3 years of consistent running and I think this qualifies. The last 6 months has been incredible and especially the last 8 weeks as I've been basically pain free. I actually think I've learned how to run in the past few months, as a result of the prior couple years of trial and error (of course, there's always much more to learn).
My damaged left ankle was analyzed last week and it has reduced substantially in size and is very close to the same size as my right ankle. It's almost as strong as my right ankle, and the flexibility in left ankle has increased tenfold and is very close to the flexibility of my right ankle.
I was told by much more experience and accomplished runners that it takes "3 years of consistent running" before your body adapts and you reap the true benefits. I'm a believer.
When I think of the last 3 years, honestly it's overwhelming. In some ways I get emotional because I went through a lot and had to knock down so many walls. I had so much support along the way (my PT, running coach, etc.) and specifically Barefoot Ted's group was one of the main reasons I made it as it was that group of folks that gave me the strength to continue many times (I mean that). Just thinking of how to describe to someone what I went through for 3 years is overwhelming . . . at times; I don't know where to start.
Now my mission is to help anyone I can. I can't tell you what it has been like the last 8 weeks to wake up and have no pain (other than normal nagging stuff). To walk at work after I cool down and have no pain. To get out of my chair at work and not worry about the next step. To wake up in the morning without pain. To walk with my kids without pain.
I wish I could name each individual that helped me but the list would be too long but I thank each and every one of you. Now, I'll do all I can do help anyone else.
HHH
Wednesday, July 28, 2010
Do What You Love
At my group track session this morning (about 25 folks) we broke off into groups because the majority of runners are preparing for a full marathon and half marathon in the next few weeks. It was funny because there were of 4 of us remaining that were not training for a half or full marathon. Several folks were surprised that I wasn't running the upcoming marathon and asked why. I actually had to pause and then I smiled because the answer was so easy . . . I don't like the long distances. They looked confused and I said when I did run marathons it finally hit me that I did it only because that's what everyone does and I finally realized neither the actual race nor training was fun. However, once I discovered speed and middle distances, the love of running returned.
I told them my favorite training run in the world is the 1 hr. run. (20 min. warm-up, 20 min. progressive, 20 min. hard). I guess this is why the 5k and 10k are my favorite races. Funny thing is I only run about 15% fewer miles per week than when I ran marathons but I'm healthier, stronger and faster.
It was an interesting morning because I'm wondering if there are others with similar experiences. Seems most runners, even newbie’s, naturally gravitate toward the marathon distance. However, the elites all mastered shorter distances first and some never move up to the marathon distance.
Anyway, that got me thinking.
HHH
Tuesday, July 27, 2010
600 Mile Threshold and Going Strong
Monday, July 26, 2010
My Wayward Left Ankle
When I was video taped for the first time 3 years ago (in 14 oz. motion control Mizuno's), I had a mid-foot strike (I'm sure I had some heel strikes also) but my left ankle would do this thing there where it would slightly whip out to the left then align straight milliseconds before landing so the PT dismissed it because the actual landing was fine. I never thought about it again as I attributed it to all the basketball injuries to my left ankle and I figured the left ankle was pretty weak so it would flare out slightly as a result and then I could bring it back in prior to landing. As a side note, if you read the article is Runner's World about Meb (he is on the cover; a few months ago) he had something similar as they described one of his ankles as a "wayward" ankle and they worked on strengthening the entire side of his body to control and align the ankle for a more solid and straight foot plant (of course, Meb is a massive heel striker so there may be other issues with him as he is injured more often than he is healthy).
I had to work (and continue of course) on my entire left side of the body starting with my arms. My coach said I ran stiff for a long time and it was evident in my upper body and then I figured out how to relax and she said all the stiffness in my upper body is now completely gone. I did this by taking a note from Gordon Pirie and I forgot I had arms. I completely ignored my arms, relaxed and completely focused on my feet . . . everything about my feet . . . all brain waves went to my feet from foot lift to strike. I needed to communicate with my feet much better and that worked and I still do not think much about my upper body other than to relax which actually resulted in my arms moving a big higher and more compact (more like the East Africans as opposed to say Ryan Hall as my arms were much lower as with Ryan . . . so that was a major change in my arm placement).
Then, per the direction from my coach, I started focusing 100-150 meters ahead and running to that point then when I get within 50 meters I set another mark 100-150 meters ahead. As I started to do this, I think it exposed my defect because I started to run straight to the point I was focusing on and then it happened . . . the "ah ha" moment because as I was running toward a point my shoulders, hips and foot aligned better. Then, instead of focusing on my foot plant, I imagined a straight line that I needed to land on with each foot plant and then I just focusing on moving forward and everything started to feel better. This also forced me to concentrate on the shorter stride which felt great. My thought is the longer I'm in the air, the more chances there is for me to "mess up," and land incorrectly and lose control of my form.
As Gordon Pirie said, "don't let your body decide when the foot should land as you must force that foot down quickly . . . get the foot on the ground as quickly as possible . . . shorten the stride and quicken up." As I speed up I focus even more on the shorter stride (not a choppy stride) but a smooth easy shorter stride that feels very natural (I make sure to not fight my body but, at the same time, I won't let my body take huge strides either).
I need a video to confirm but I'm pretty confident the result is that I don't land on the severe outer edge of my left foot anymore. I still land on the outside and roll in but not as severe. That slight whipping action had to put stress on my ankle and specifically the plantar muscle which had to work over-time to re-align my ankle prior to landing.
HHH
Saturday, July 24, 2010
Major Flaw Detected & Corrected
Thursday, July 22, 2010
Recent Developments
Obviously there's been a lot of discussion since Dathan's announcement that he has changed from a heel strike to a mid-foot strike with good commentary from Burfoot, Steve Magness and our own Pete.
However, something still bothers me. I'm not a scientist, coach or professor. I'm a former attorney that thinks big picture and is very visual. I tend to take complicated issues and try to make them as simple as possible for any lay person to understand. I defer to others that have a better understanding of the science behind running.
However, with that said, the simple thing, in my mind, that gets overlooked when it comes to analyzing stride and foot plant is Dr. Lieberman's point which is comparing barefoot stride vs. shod stride (whether it's minimalist footwear or traditional shoes). Is not barefoot running the most natural way to run and the best way to allow the body to take over? If so, if you run differently when barefoot vs. anything on your feet, isn't that the starting point for your analysis?
If you believe the human body is amazing and engineered to survive without Nike, then wouldn't barefoot be the starting point. I just don't buy the "I've been running is regular shoes for 40 yrs. so it's not possible to make the switch." The switch is back to your natural gait. Yes, it takes patience and baby steps but the transition is to the natural way to run. I understand there are elements to deal with like weather so maybe barefoot means the most minimalist footwear possible to account for weather and/or terrain but the point remains. I think this is a patience and confidence issue. We lack patience to take a long term approach and we lack confidence in the human body.
I'll put the elites in a different category because that's a different ballgame and goal. It's a different "risk/reward" situation. Elites push everything to the edge with the goal to "win" at all costs (even my approach to my insignificant small races is different than training wherein I'm willing to "cheat" at bit to place or win a race and I accept that).
We so under-estimate the human body, and we over-rely on technology to out perform the natural body.
Although I'm thrilled with the fact that these issues are coming to the surface, I'm a bit frustrated with the direction and focus at times. Many times the very simple "ah ha" gets over-looked through all the deep analysis (I'm not saying we don't need deep analysis because we do but don't let it over-shadow some obvious things).
HHH
Wednesday, July 21, 2010
Elite Runner Stops Heel Striking
Dathan Ritzenhein Switches from Heel to Midfoot Strike: "I think I'm more efficient"
The vast majority of runners strike with the heel when they hit the ground, and the recent minimalist running trend has led to more and more runners attmepting to shift to a more midfoot or forefoot landing style. Although there is anecdotal evidence out there supporting the shift, what we don't know definitively, at least from a scienftific standpoint, is whether shifting from a heel strike to a midfoot or forefoot strike will result in a more efficient gait, or one that is less prone to causing injury.
Well, here's another anecdote, this time from elite runner Dathan Ritzenhein. If you don't know who Ritzenhein is, he set the US record for the 5K last year(since broken by Bernard Lagat) and represented the United States in the Marathon at the 2008 Summer Olympics in Beijing. In an article on the Runner's World website by Peter Gambaccini, Riteznehein discusses his plans to race in the New York City Marathon this Fall, as well as how he has modified his gait to from a heel to a midfoot strike to help deal with some recurring injuries. His coach at Nike, Alberto Salazar, also discusses Ritzenhien's gait change. What I like about this article is that it shows how an elite feels about the move from heel to midfoot, and also that he has some personal idiosyncracies in his anatomy that necessitated shoe modifications. All to often we forget that we humans are highly variable, and that what works for one may not work for all.
Quote from Alberto Salazar on Ritzhenhein's injuries and his shoe insert inGambaccini's Runner's World article:
"Dathan continues to have some foot problems which he's had for years. I had thought that just by keeping him on soft surfaces and making sure that he's recovered that this would be taken care of. But he continued to have metatarsal problems...
...We finally decided to do some in-depth studies. Gordon Valiant, who's the head of biomechanics for Nike, did an evaluation of Dathan and he was able to find some things that were unique to Dathan – just the way he runs and how he strikes his foot. With that, we have modified inserts – I wouldn't call them orthotics, I would just call them an insert in the shoe with a sort of excavation type depression in this area where he has an abnormal amount of force near his third metatarsal (on his right foot). And with that, it seems to have alleviated his symptoms completely…"
Quote from Dathan Ritzenhein on his gait change in Gambaccini's Runner's World article:
"I was definitely more of a heel-striker, so I'm definitely getting on to my midfoot more. I wouldn't say I get all the way up to my toe. I think I'm more efficient for the marathon if I stay in more of a midfoot stance anyway. But definitely, the posture of my body and the range of my stride, that's all stuff that has just kind of come through. Initially, the problem was we tried to focus solely on changing that without being strong enough to do it. We went back to trying to build it up from the strength side so it (the stride change) naturally took over instead of trying to think about it consciously. So that's the point where we'd at now; it's just a subconscious thing and I don't have to consciously think about changing my form anymore."
Thursday, July 15, 2010
Another Bridge Crossed In My Journey
I have to say this latest experiment has been the best and most educational experiment for me to date. That is, returning to running shoes to compare against running in the Evo's and barefoot. It took a long time to reach the point where I could run in shoes without pain or injury so this provided me the opportunity to make a good comparison. Today was so clear (more than yesterday). I've completed the last few weeks of speed/interval track work in the zero dropped Nike Free 3.0's but today I returned to the Evo's and did 1x800 meters, into 8x300 meters, finishing with 1x800 meters. The difference was very clear. Again, I was sharper and cleaner.
However, the real difference is the communications paths were all open. I can't put an exact number or percentage on it but I'd say I had another 10-15% awareness of my body. I was able to make adaptations in mid-stride because the communications paths from my forefoot to ankle to leg to brain were wide open. I could literally feel my body at work in the Evo's and barefoot . . . I could feel the same in the Free's but not to the same extent. It was like trying to hear someone speak while you have ear phones on, with no music playing . . . just the plain ear phones. The ear phones just deafen the ears just a bit but enough that it's noticeable.
I think my long distance days may be over. I was thinking about it while do the intervals. All things considered, I think I'm built and designed for middle distance. Gordon Pirie wasn't lying when he said, "Speed kills endurance and Endurance kills speed." Funny to think 18 months ago my long runs were 20-30 miles and now my long run is 10-12 miles, but I can run those shorter miles efficiently with proper form
and technique.
I'm also frustrated that this group can't reach more people. I think we all have so much to offer others. It kills me to watch someone slam into the ground. It kills me to hear runners just accept that they must deal with serious injuries due to running.
HHH
Tuesday, July 13, 2010
Evo vs. Nike Free vs. Nike Run+ - Correction
First, let me say that I know I'm schizophrenic and I apologize for that :). I just received the final results of my last two 5k races and I was faster in the Evo's vs. the zero dropped Nike Free 3.0's, although I placed second in the race in the Evo's and won the race with the Nike Free's. Also, the course I ran in the Evo's was tougher than the course in the Free's as I spent a lot of time analyzing the courses last night and the race in the Free's had more hills but they were smaller while the race in the Evo's had a 1.25 mile gradual uphill climb on the loop toward the finish (I'll take the short hills any day because you get the immediate downhill and mentally it's easier to deal with). In other words, my performance in the Evo's exceeded my performance in the Free's.
I only share this for what it's worth as I've tried several experiments on myself and tried to keep it as close to an apples-to-apples comparison as possible.
I've spent 2 weeks running in the zero dropped Free 3.0's and Run+'s but this morning I returned to the Evo's. I've put about 140 miles on the Free's/Run+'s so my body had time to adjust. I enjoyed running in them and experienced no major pain or injury. I also held my goal times pretty well and tested the shoes on various terrains and elevations. However, as I returned to my Evo's today, among other things, the two words that describes the difference is "CLEAN," and "SHARP," all in favor of the Evo. My run in the Evo's is cleaner and sharper.
It's really interesting because the "energy return," is a comparison between the actual foot vs. the additional cushion. It's really a comparison between the natural functions of the foot/arch and the sole, cushion and mild arch support in the shoe. I've hard coded in my brain most of the elements of good running form and technique but I have to take a more active role in ensuring proper form and technique in the Free's/Run+'s vs. the Evo's. I don't have to think as much in the Evo's as it's easier for the natural body to take over. I can't confirm this but I believe I have a longer stride in the Evo's vs. the Free's/Run's which, on first thought, may be counter-intuitive. I probably actively shorten the stride in more traditional shods while the Evo's, and of course barefoot, provide for a much more natural reaction.
As for the cushioning, yes, it makes a difference. I can't tie it to injury or pain but it feels completely different. With less cushion, I'm a cleaner and sharper runner.
Now, I did do a little barefoot running and that provides an interesting distinction and discussion, at least in my mind, when comparing the Evo to barefoot running. To date, I am faster in the Evo's vs. barefoot and it may be physical or psychological, or a bit of both is probably the case.
I'm having a blast with some of these micro-analysis experiments on myself. Bottom line, is I think Amby Burfoot, Christopher McDougall and that Doctor dude are all correct when they say, "run in the most minimal shoe you can get away with." As with many things in life, when you hit the point where you can add support to the human body but it doesn't need it, you probably should not add it.
Hope some of this is interesting to some folks.
HHH
